Skip to main content

Was Brian Hartline a "really, really bad" hire for USF? (Deep breath) Absolutely not

ByJoe Henderson
USF Bulls coach Brian Hartline
USF Bulls coach Brian Hartline | Image courtesy USF athletics

The last 24 hours have been extraordinary in the amount of noise around the South Florida football program.

Following a blowout loss at FAU, frustrated Bulls fans focused their anger on head coach Brian Hartline. Yahoo sports pundit Dan Wolken stoked the fire with a blunt tweet that read "Brian Hartline was a really bad hire for South Florida - really, really bad."

While not questioning his right to post whatever his opinion on this issue might be, that tweet seemed rather random. Why, with everything else happening in college football now, would a first-year head coach at a Group of 6 program attract this kind of attention and judgment?

Curious.

There was some thought in the Twitterverse that USF should hit a hard reboot of the program after this season, starting with Hartline and going from there.

There were reports -- unnamed sources, mind you -- about infighting between unidentified members of the coaching staff. Still others, speaking earnestly, said some players were complaining about double standards in the locker room.

Others unloaded on CEO of Athletics Rob Higgins.

Deep breath.

Allow me, if you will, to add some perspective to what obviously is a disturbing situation for USF's flagship athletic program.

Start with this point: Will USF fire Hartline after one season?

No.

Anyone suggesting otherwise is being ridiculous. At worst, the Bulls will finish the regular season at 6-6. Can you imagine how firing a coach who was a celebrated hire 11 months ago for finishing 6-6 would reverberate throughout the college football universe?

USF would be a laughing stock and no credible coach would want anything to do with this program in that case.

But the status quo doesn't work either. It seems a given that a significant staff overhaul is in USF's future, and that needs to happen.

Here's why. It's not because these are bad coaches, either. It's about chemistry.

Hartline was hired while serving as co-offensive coordinator at Ohio State. The Buckeyes were preparing to play in the Big Ten championship game just days are the announcement that he was coming to USF. After that, the Buckeyes were in the College Football Playoff.

College Football Bracket Challenge

GET READY TO COMPETE

Pick your champion (you can change it later). We’ll email you when brackets open.

No purchase necessary. 50 U.S./D.C. 18+. Entry opens 3PM ET Dec 6, 2026 and closes 8PM ET Dec 18, 2026. Void where prohibited.See for complete details. The College Football Playoff (CFP) is not a sponsor or administrator of this contest.

He was pulled between competing forces -- the need to quickly assemble a staff and roster vs. preparing the Buckeyes for a playoff run. He couldn't devote full energy to both. Not only that, he had spent his coaching career at Ohio State, which meant that he had a limited pool of contacts for potential staff members.

When Alex Golesh came to USF, he had made several coaching stops and had a wider circle to draw from. Hartline not only lacked that, he didn't have the advantage of time to sift through dozens of potential hires to find the "right" choices.

How many of those coaches were recommended by headhunters or agents, pushing an angle? Either way, I'll say with certainty that they were not all Hartline's "guys." There wasn't time to form that kind of deep relationship. That vital chemistry between the head coach and some members of his staff seems to be missing,

The same went for players. After so much of USF's talent transferred after Golesh left, Hartline was left with a swiss cheese roster filled with guys who came from elsewhere who might fit into the system Hartline hoped to create, or might not.

Another deep breath. This isn't just a football problem, it requires all the top-level assistance the athletic department can provide.

This is where Derrick Brooks and Lelo Prado come in. These men, top leaders in USF's athletic department, have been forged in the fire of high-level competition for their adult lives. They can provide Hartline guidance on how to navigate the tough choices that lie ahead.

For that matter, they can do the same for Higgins as he deals with the first real crisis since he took over the athletic program 14 months ago. His pet saying -- all gas, no brakes -- makes a fine soundbite, but perhaps this is one time when pumping the brakes a bit would be in order.

That might start with respectfully declining a bowl bid, no matter what happens in the regular-season finale against Tulane. The Bulls will likely be dealing with major staff turnover by then, and who knows how many players will opt out of the game anyway.

Instead of preparation for a game that doesn't mean much (remember the Cure Bowl? Me either), USF would be better served by preparing for 2027 with better staff alignment and securing a recruiting class and Transfer Portal additions that fit what Hartline wants to do.

Stay tuned, Bulls Nation. Whatever happens, I can only tell you this.

I've been around and covered sports for almost all of my adult life. I have a good idea of how things work -- when a situation is beyond help, and when it is not.

USF hit a pothole this season, no question about that. The natural tendency is to blame to coach.

But was Hartline a "really bad hire for South Florida - really, really bad."

Even in today's microwaved college football world, t's way too soon to say that.

If I'm wrong, I'll own it.

But I'm not wrong.

Add us as a preferred source on Google